Online Rating Sheet

Online Rating Sheet

Reviewer's Name:
Email Address:
Date of Review:
Manuscript Reference Number:
Manuscript Title:

RATING OF MANUSCRIPT

Low				High
1	2	3	4	5
					Importance to our readers
					Originality of the research
					Prescriptive element*
					Clarity of writing
					Use of supporting materials

* Does the piece contain suggestions on how to improve implementation of current laws or policies or propose new laws or policies to effectuate the objective of conserving wildlife species?

RECOMMENDATION TO THE EDITOR

Accept with moderate revision

Possibly accept after major revision

Reject (publishable, but not in this journal)

This piece would be more appropriate for the following journal(s):

Reject (not worthy of publication)

I have written comments on some pages of the manuscript. I will return the manuscript by mail.

I have not written comments on the manuscript, so I am not returning it. I recognize that it is the intellectual property of the author(s) and will dispose of it.